The Caffeine Controversy: Is It Acceptable to Bring Iced Coffee to a Job Interview?


A student sits drinking iced coffee at Brewpoint in Elmhurst. || Photo by Star Herring
There’s been controversy on social media within recent weeks on whether it’s professional to bring an iced coffee to a job interview, brewing a debate regarding interview etiquette.
A job recruiter named Caitlin Wehnianen posted a video on TikTok focusing on how a lot of Gen Z applicants are bringing iced coffees to interviews. Wehnianen said in the TikTok video that it’s unprofessional and that bringing an iced coffee is distracting.
“It’s perceived from my perspective, from my hiring standpoint, when you show up with an iced coffee that this interview is just a stop on your list of errands for the day,” Wehnianen said. “It looks like you went to Target, you went to Starbucks, you’re stopping by your interview, and then you’re onto the next thing. It looks a little too casual to me.”
Wehnianen’s opinion sparked an online debate over what is considered unprofessional during a job interview. The discussion touched on topics such as timeliness, clothing, and attitude.
“I think somebody’s attention would be directed towards the coffee,” junior Ava Arthur said. “Not to mention, you could drink the coffee before the interview. I think water is okay if you need to clear your throat.”
Elmhurst University student Alex Knapik said how important the context of the interview and job is. Some hiring managers are more biased on the topic than others, and there really is no way to know if they are beforehand. It all depends on the hiring manager and the work environment of the particular job.
“I would argue the best choice is to err to the side of caution and keep the coffee in the car,” Knapik said. “If the position matters to the individual, the risk of bringing the ice coffee outweighs simply not bringing it all. It is unlikely that an interviewer will reject you for not having a coffee with you, but there is a possibility of creating a bad first impression if you do.”
Content creators and job recruiters are torn on whether bringing an iced coffee is professional, and on interview etiquette in general.
Martin Gahbauer, the executive director of EU’s Weigand Career Center for Professional Excellence, has been a part of the university’s Marketing and Advertising department for 23 years. He’s hired many staff members and recently hired three new staff this summer. Gahbauer has sat in on multiple hiring committees at EU for other departments.
“You’re in the playoffs and you want to win, right? So you want to present yourself in the best possible manner. Professionalism is important,” Gahbauer, who believes iced coffee can sometimes be distracting in an interview, said.
As Gen Z has entered the workforce, Gahbauer said he’s noticed a change in business culture.
“You could have an interview in the lobby of a hotel or a coffee shop,” Gahbauer said. “The job interview processes have become different. If you’re in a coffee shop, that makes sense. If you’re in a formal interview setting, a cup of iced coffee will be a distraction.”
Rhonda Humphrey-Jenkins was recently hired for the Entrepreneur in Residence position in the WCCPE.
Humphrey-Jenkins said that she and her millennial daughter had their own debate regarding bringing iced coffee to a job interview. They agreed it shouldn’t be a disqualifying factor.
“You’ve done nothing wrong. If you are qualified for the position that’s all that should matter,” Humphrey-Jenkins, who has worked in corporate offices and on hiring committees for years, said.


